News

Public versus Private: Which is best for your kids?

Tahlia and Jacob Lymbery at students at St Eugene College. Photo Vicki Wood / Caboolture News
Tahlia and Jacob Lymbery at students at St Eugene College. Photo Vicki Wood / Caboolture News Vicki Wood

WITH back-to-school time just around the corner, the public-versus-private school debate is back in the spotlight, and is one that can cause angst for parents.

Price is often a swaying factor in the decision, but there are plenty of other arguments for and against either side.

So where do you stand?

Natasha Christian speaks with parents on how they made their decision.

 

PUBLIC

FOR Marie Dawson, the decision to send her daughter Kaitlyn to Bribie State High School was made easy with the help of her primary school principal.

Ms Dawson was searching for a school that would continue a high-quality music program similar to what her daughter had experienced at Banksia Beach State School.

"Principal Jacqui King mentioned she worked closely with Bribie High School. That's why we decided to send her there. A lot of her friends go there as well," she said.

"Based on what Ms King has said, we are going to stick with Bribie."

While Kaitlyn was yet to start high school, she already had plans for the future to study at university to become a lawyer.

Marie felt sending her to a public school would place her at no disadvantage to achieve this.

"We've met with the counsellor and vice-principal at Bribie and we are very excited."

A bit of an all-rounder, Kaitlyn is also keen on sports. However, Marie felt sport was not a reason to sway decisions on schools.

"We will put her into a club. Sporting is good, but for the future, you need the academic sector," she said.

As for primary schools, Marie was also getting ready to start her son in grade one at Banksia Beach.

"He will be taking part in the music program as well," she said.

 

Pros and cons of public schools

Pro: Money can be saved for future expenses such as university, travelling and first car.

Pro: Some say it's more "real world" experience, with wider socio-economic and ethnic diversity.

Pro/con: Not affiliated with any religion.

Pro/con: Only co-ed.

Con: Generally larger class sizes.

Con: Relies solely on government funding, which can be limited.

 

PRIVATE

THERESA Lymbery knew she had made the right decision in sending her children to St Eugene Catholic College when her daughter Tahlia graduated as vice-captain with an OP 4.

With her son Jacob about to start Year 11, Theresa was confident he would go down a similar path.

"Our major concern with putting the kids into the state system when the time came was that they would be lost in the system," she said.

"The state primary schools in the region are so large, with so many preschoolers/preppies starting on day one, and I hated the thought of them being just another face in the crowd."

She said St Eugene offered a smaller school with a community where she felt welcomed from the first time she walked through the gates.

"We started with the parents' group, where we met families that were already enrolled into the school and had older children attending and had positive feedback from them."

While she said she was concerned about the costs, she said the close-knit community made it worth it for her kids.

"I feel that they have more connection with the community and community issues," she said.

"St Eugene has a buddy system that buddies big kids with little kids, which makes the transition from lower to middle to upper school grades easier.

"It gives the little kids a personal connection with seniors so they don't appear big and scary, and it gives the seniors a sense of responsibility. I feel that this gives the kids more confidence and that certainly would be an advantage in later life."

While Theresa acknowledged that the public system was a better choice for a lot of families, she felt the private system was the right choice for her family.

"We wanted our children to have the best education available and were concerned about falling through the cracks in the public system. However, I think if you have gifted or remedial students, that the public system is a better alternative."

 

Pros and cons of a private school

Pro: Smaller class sizes

Pro: Often private schools span primary and high school, making the school run a lot easier

Pro: Boarding facilities

Pro/con: Single-sex education available

Con: Some have suggested it is a "sheltered environment"

Con: There can be more pressure to achieve to maintain prestige.

 

What do you think? Let us know at cabnewsed@scnews.com.au.


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Hungry Jacks under fire for playground accident

Nanette Bingham's daughter suffered a nasty gash from Hungry Jack's Morayfield playground.

Hungry Jacks under fire for playground accident

Refugee keen to work after finding home in Caboolture

HAPPY FAMILY: Pema Maya Tamang, Anish Gurung and Bal Bahadur Galang love life in Australia.

Bal is desperate for a job after securing asylum in Australia.

Caboolture's adult learners look to the future

Jeanette Johnston learns from teacher Marilyn Hill leading up to Adult Learners' Week.

Caboolture Adult Literacy Centre celebrate Adult Learners' Week.

Latest deals and offers

The Caboolture Snakes win Barber Cup after 26 years

Tears of joy followed the siren for the Caboolture Snakes as they beat Springfield to win the Barber Cup and send off their retiring captain and coach.

Hungry Jacks under fire for playground accident

Nanette Bingham's daughter suffered a nasty gash from Hungry Jack's Morayfield playground.

Hungry Jacks under fire for playground accident

Refugee keen to work after finding home in Caboolture

HAPPY FAMILY: Pema Maya Tamang, Anish Gurung and Bal Bahadur Galang love life in Australia.

Bal is desperate for a job after securing asylum in Australia.

Caboolture's adult learners look to the future

Jeanette Johnston learns from teacher Marilyn Hill leading up to Adult Learners' Week.

Caboolture Adult Literacy Centre celebrate Adult Learners' Week.

Sunshine Coast commuters hit by train signal fault

TRAIN services on the Caboolture line have been suspended

Die-hard fan's 34 magic Gympie Muster years

STICK AROUND FOR A BEER: Mal Williams has been at every Gympie Muster for 34 years.

Mal Williams has only missed one Muster in 35 years - the first one

Australian Survivor's Peter: I'm no quitter

Australian Survivor contestant Peter Fiegehen.

ILLNESS forces castaway's early exit from Samoa.

Diva's sister on soliciting charge

FILE - In this May 14, 2016 file photo, Mariah Carey attends the 27th Annual GLAAD Media Awards, in New York. Carey will appear on the Oct. 5 episode of the Fox series, \"Empire,\" the network confirmed Monday at a TV critics bi-annual press tour. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP, File)

Mariah Carey's sister has been arrested on charges of prostitution.

Tom Cruise private jets his gym kit around the world

Tom Cruise

Tom Cruise charters private to take his gym kit around the world

Movie behind Depp and Heard split to be released

Soon you'll be able to see the movie that ended the marriage

Bindi's boyfriend helps release huge croc

Chandler (far right) helped the jump team.

Chandler Powell helps catch Duncan the croc

Mick Jagger to pay £2.5m to the woman carrying his baby

Mick Jagger is reportedly paying millions to pregnant ballerina

Housing market going strong as units face tougher times

One real estate sector looks set for a rocky 2017

REVEALED: Pat Rafter's $18m Coast house on the market

Check out the photos of the Coast's most expensive property for sale

The "correction we had to have" in Gladstone's rentals

UPWARD MARCH: The rental vacancy rate in Gladstone has improved for the first time in more than a year, providing a confidence boost in the market.

Vacancy rates improve with signs that things are getting betterF

ISLAND FOR SALE: Cheap Fraser Coast island drops price again

Suna Island in the Great Sandy Strait will be auctioned by Ray White Hervey Bay on Saturday morning.

This is the cheapest island you will find for sale in Australia

How a family home can fit on a 250sq m block

This is what you can build on 250m2.

Here's the floor plan of a home built on 250sq m

$100m plan for Curtis Island 'world class' luxury resort

$100 million resort: Top views at Turtle Street at Curtis Island.

"At the moment we think it meets all the town planning approvals.”